UM New Church Starts Stand Out in National Survey


From Discipleship Ministries of The United Methodist Church

NASHVILLE, Tenn. Discipleship Ministries– United Methodist new church starts outpaced new church starts by other protestant denominations in three of five key benchmarks – average worship attendance, new decisions for Christ and reaching previously unchurched people – according to a survey of 17 U.S. evangelical denominations and church planting network organizations.

"...the survey shows us verifiable proof that the efforts of our annual conferences to improve our church planting process is yielding positive results."

The survey, conducted in 2015 by LifeWay Research, received responses from 1,200 pastors and new church leaders and focused on 843 church plants started since 2008. LifeWay said the church planting survey was the most thorough in almost a decade.

“I believe the survey shows us verifiable proof that the efforts of our annual conferences to improve our church planting process is yielding positive results,” said Bob Crossman, a New Church Strategist with Path1, a division of Discipleship Ministries of The United Methodist Church. “It also shows that we need to be not only encouraging our existing churches to become stronger and more viable, but we need to be continuing to start new churches and new places the reach new people.”

United Methodists represented 11.5 percent of the respondents to the nationwide survey, which also included churches from Assemblies of God, Baptist Missionary Association of America, Christian and Missionary Alliance, Church of the Nazarene, Converge Worldwide, Evangelical Free Church of America, Free Methodist Church USA, International Pentecostal Holiness Church, Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod, Missionary Church, New Thing Network, Presbyterian Church in America, Project Jerusalem, Southern Baptist Convention, Vineyard Church, and The Wesleyan Church.


Bar graph showing UMC new church performance by year vs new

“One of the surprising findings is that the United Methodist new churches exceeded the average worship attendance of the typical new church start in the United States in each of the first five years of the new church,” Crossman said. “I had assumed that the Pentecostal churches and the Baptist churches – these large, strong evangelical churches – would have far greater worship attendance than the United Methodists.”
United Methodist planters also exceeded the typical new church in receiving new decisions for Christ during the first five years. The UMC churches averaged a total of 84 new commitments, while the typical new church in the survey had 78.

The typical new church witnesses 78 new commitments in the first 5 years. UM planters witness 84. Bar graph comparison over those 5 years.

“The third surprise for me is that the United Methodist churches out-performed the typical new church in reaching those who were previously unchurched or unchurched for many years,” Crossman said. “I guess a more common way to put it is United Methodist new churches were not stealing sheep from other churches. We were reaching people who do not have a church background and doing that more effectively than the typical new church in the United States.”

In the typical new church, 42% were unchurched. In UMC new churches, 52% were. Bar graph showing rates of unchurched, unchurched for many years, and other church backgrounds

United Methodists need to improve in two benchmarks areas included in the survey. New UMC churches were less likely to become self-sustaining within the first five years. In the typical new church, more than half – 64 percent – were financially self-sustaining by the fifth year, compared to 42 percent for the United Methodists.
The second area that needed improvement for UMC new church starts was multiplying, or giving birth to another new church. In the survey, 22 percent of the typical new churches started a daughter church within the first five years, compared to only 13 percent among United Methodist churches.
“The survey has already begun to help us by revealing key statistically verifiable factors that have a correlation to reaching these five critical benchmarks,” Crossman said. “So as a result, already in our training, coaching and supervising, we are able to lay before our potential planters and actual planters in the field factors that are worth them testing in their mission field to see if they will yield results.”
Every mission field is different, and regions of the country are also different, Crossman said.
“But if there is a particular activity that has yielded fruit nationwide – that resulted in an amazing benchmark – then our planters need to be testing that in their mission field,” he said “Now we have statistically verifiable factors, rather than just random observations or hunches about what might be effective.”
Over the past ten years, UMC annual conferences have learned the importance of accessing the potential planters' gifts and graces before sending them to the mission field, Crossman said.
“We've also learned the importance of sending planters to mission fields that they have a natural affinity to reach for the Gospel,” he said. “We've learned the importance of having a discipleship system and a stewardship system in place immediately in the new church, along with a positive relationship with a coach.
“Beginning in 2016, the additional significant factors revealed in this survey have the potential to help our new church efforts reach higher levels of health and vitality, making more disciples, more diverse disciples, and more younger disciples for Christ,” he said.
Read Path1’s executive summary of the LifeWay survey » 

For a copy of the full survey, email Candace Lewis, Executive Director of Path 1 New Church Starts,